It’s the second game of the season and Fizdale’s starting lineup actually makes sense!
Elfrid Payton will start at the point alongside RJ Barrett, with Marcus Morris and Julius Randle paired with Mitchell Robinson returning from an injury to take the starting center spot. I knew Fizdale couldn’t be so dumb as to start Portis over Mitch (well, okay, I was pretty sure).
That’s the most competent Knick starting lineup in YEARS!
It’ll be interesting seeing the Brooklyn Kyries in action. If Minnesota could beat them, the Knicks can beat them!
Let’s go, Knicks!
231 replies on “2019-20 Game Thread: Knicks @ the Brooklyn Kyries”
payton and mitch starting… took a game but we got there…
Thank God ! Starting 5 that makes perfect sense.
Someone had sex last night !
It would be so sweet if the Knicks could win this one…but…
How many mins for frank tonite?
Before RegSeason started i predicted a L for this one.
After the SA game I’m optimist we can get a W.
But We should bring the A Game for 48m.
Kyrie: “Tonight I’m gonna make the Knicks pay for me not wanting to play there!”
Frank plays from 0 to 20min on Kyrie
depending on Elf’s D & on Frank’s TOs.
This Nets public announcer is kinda whack on the lo…
Couldn’t watch much opening night, looking forward to being able to watch this back-to-back vs BK and Boston. Would be nice to at least win 1 of these 2 this weekend.
Not sure Mitch should be out there. Looks gimpy.
Although he also looks like he has filled out a bit
RJ showing his rebounding ability there.
Randle really needs to get a tighter handle
Kyrie will score 70 tonite
Kyrie might shoot 30 free throws tonight
Mitch looked fine on that rebound and put-back.
If Joe Harris is gonna be covering Morris he has to be able to punish him down low.
It’s also my first time I’m able to watch. My first impression, the Knicks are not very good on defense, but it’s still considerably better than their offense at the moment. I’m not complaining, but it’s certainly different from recent past teams.
Yeah he did. His go go gadget arms are very useful for basketball.
Mitch is going for the 5 by 5 game
Mitch is already collecting stats like no big deal.
mitch is doing mitch things but he’s still at square negative one with some fundamentals. kyrie coming at him one on one to the hole the absolute last thing he should be doing is reaching down with both arms.
Walt comping Mitch to Willis, both from Louisiana
Also notes he saw snow for the first time in Denver last year….
I like that first sub by fiz
Mitch looks like he’s learning to roller skate
taurean prince is oddly strong. randle morris and portis have all failed to move him in the post
Mitch sits down and it’s dunkathon time for the Nets
This is not a good defensive lineup
Good luck with that shit
that was knox’s man but randle had plenty of room on the dho to help on the switch; his help D is just not going to be there consistently
DSJ is from Fayetteville? I know some dear friends from North Carolina in the Army where Ft. Bragg is located in that city. They call it FayetteNam.
Knox is looking like a legit 3-pt threat. Now if he can play tough D.
Knox can’t defend worth a shit but he sure can knock down that 3. There’s a real future for him when he fills out, matures and shows the strength to play power forward.
Portis is such waste.
Why did the Knicks give Portis a 15m per yr contract again??????
That is why we need a second rim protector
Painful to watch DSJ shoot.
Portis and Smith are like this year’s Hezonga and Mudiay, except even worse
Did he get with Markelle’s shot coach this summer?
Dsjr can finish a layup either!
Knox is not a ball handler. Stop that.
So this 2nd unit sucks.
Bench is shit tonight….
lol knox bounced off dinwiddie like he was pj tucker
I cross fingers for FizMagic !
Pretty funny to watch the nyets open up a 15 point lead with Kyrie on the bench….
Refs are kind human beings
Seems like DSj went halvsies with Frank on a shooting coach.
Knox looked completely unable to do anything on that fast break. No stutter step or use of his length, just barreling into traffic like always.
Taj Gibson should get all of Portis’s minutes.
Knox should not be guarding 2-guards.
Knox hoisted 4 shots in 7 minutes? Impressive…
Nice to see the Nets run a modern offense with good guards and tons of shooters, maybe one of these days the Knicks will join the 21st century and do the same.
Lol @ Mitch
2 of Mitch Rob’s fouls are against Kyrie.
Maybe they should try a Bobby/Mitch front court?
This game got really boring in a hurry. Watching Pelicans-Dallas.
Our team looks so clueless compared to the Nets. Its insane how little of an idea our players seem to show on both ends of the court.
What other game is on?
Apparently I haven’t watched DSJ shoot enough like yall have. That j has no chance.
WTF was Barrett doing?
Payton with a worse post pass than either of the two Frank made that everyone lost their shit over …. No real reason to believe Payton is better than Frank. Fizdale doesn’t like foreigners and thinks Frank has a lower floor, there’s no more to it than that.
Lots of playground ball…
Knicks look so much slower and less athletic than the Nets.
Knicks are doubling Kyrie as soon as he touches the ball.
BKN’s gonna score 60+ in the first half, all the while one of the best defending PGs in the association stays glued to the bench for Elfrid Payton and Dennis Smith, Jr.
It’s the fuckin trier show
Who said earlier that the national media thinks the Nets are taking over NY? These Laker heads are buying the hype hook, line and sinker… until I let them know what’s really good.
Pels 15-18 from the floor. 3/4 from 3 and 12/15 inside the restricted area…. zero mid range stuff.
the big shot blocking rim protector has one block and 0 boards
I’d watch more of this, but it’s Friday Night Soccer here in East LA. No Robert Randolph band playing in the background here, tho.
Like Greg Anthony used to say, we might lose the game but we aint gonna lose the fight.
Should have been out of bounds… done
Payton >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> DS Jr and Frank
Payton is the Enes Kanter of PG defense. Brutal.
I guess my first impression about Knick defense was wrong.
It’s amazing how little of an offensive system we have. Our offense is just isolation based on who wants to shoot it at the moment.
Mavs gave up 41 to the pels in the first 12 minutes….
Not a good half. Some bad shooting. Missed a lot of layups but give credit to the Nets for tight interior defense. RJ and Randle are a combined 4-16.
I don’t have audio, did they just declare it a jump ball?
Who was fightin’?
Unfortunately I’m stuck watching the Nets feed.
That’s because Fizdale is a bad coach.
“Randle malfunctioning, coughs it up.” Clyde sums up Randle unforced error. He’s fumbled the ball away at least three times this half. Tighten up dude.
Randle would have fit in perfectly on like the 1978 Buffalo Braves. In 2019? Not so much.
This team is not going to be any good until we clean house of Mills, Perry and Fizdale. None of the three knows a damn thing about basketball. Fizdale is so bad I’d rather have Isiah Thomas coaching. The ultimate responsibility is Dolan’s because he keeps surrounding himself with incompetents, but it’s his team. We aren’t likely to get rid of him. Our best hope is that he lucks into some basketball people that know how to evaluate talent, prioritize the right things, and ultimately play the right players. This Nets team minus Durant is not especially good or talented. They just play good basketball. The problem is they are playing against a team coached by a snake oil salesman that has no idea who his best players are, how to fit them together, or how to create anything coherent on either side.
Don’t hold back Strat
Portis has the best knicks +/- so far: 0
Fizdale alienated his best player, widely-respected throughout the league and in Europe, after little more than a year.(*) Yet somehow Mills and Perry have tried to pitch him as some kind of master culture-builder with a great rep throughout the league who a bunch of people would rush to play for. Bizarre.
(*) And didn’t move Porzingis’s needle even an iota.
Porzingis has 16 points in 8 minutes but no rebounds.
Trier has such a bizarre skill set, can only hit long threes on the move and get fouled near the hoop, nothing else.
The man is speaking truth to power…..
Payton with an iso near airball and then a loaf job at the three point line on defense to start the second half. He sucks.
Good time out by Fiz, that was unacceptable.
Quickest timeout ever called by fiz?
these quick TOs scream fake coach hustle
Fuck you, strat. Just fuck you.
Yeah, real quick timeout by Fiz.
This is awful. Put trier back in
Put in Frank and whoever. That kid from Michigan.
I’m watching Knicks/Dallas simultaneously.
Porzingis looks great on offense tonight given he’s not getting double teamed and the coach is actually getting him the ball in good spots. lol However, he looks a little slower on defense. You can’t tell much from 2 games and pre season, but it looks like he came back in much better shape and more confident in his body than most players coming back from an ACL injury.
Pelicans have lost the plot too.
Thomas was a horrible GM and president, but he’s a better coach than Fizdale.
Payton just did his Derrick Rose imitation.
The Knicks have 8 steals on the night.
MitchRob has 4 of them.
Shit foray into the lane then loafed back on defense leaving Harris wide open for a 3. He’s barely even trying on defense at this point.
I hate tanking from both a sports and strategical perspective except in rare cases, but this may be one of them. The worse we are the quicker we might rid of the numb skulls in charge.
LOL it was 16 point game and Clyde says, “RJ has a knack for making shots when the game gets tight.”
Dang, RJ/KP/Mitch would’ve been a nice core.
That was nice Mitch
RJ to Mitch nice
Fizdale is going to have to tell Randle to stop.
He’s really sloppy and careless with the ball.
Strat joins us tankers??
Really, I’m just trying to enjoy RJB and Mitch developing (hopefully) into major pieces. And maybe one of Knox/Frank becoming a decent bench piece going forward. Randle can score a bit, but he doesn’t seem to do much else. Lots of bad defenders on the team, again.
Do the Nets ever miss a 3?
Damn, Barrett is a fluid scorer.
very nice quarter for RJ
How’s that guy Trier doing?
He’s completely clueless.
Do the Knicks even have plays? They clearly don’t have anything that could possibly be called “an offense,” but do they even have plays?
I wasn’t high on Fiz to begin and this season isn’t helping
Not a good shift for Taj
I agree about Fiz. He falls in love with scoring and picks players on just that.
Yeah, Fiz likes to go with hot hands, but Trier is pretty hot, so sure, play him!
lol Trier will not pass that fucking ball
To be only down 11 with the Nets hitting 50% from 3 is pretty fortunate…
This game has no pace
It’s clear that Fiz wants his 3-pt shooters to bring the Knicks back into the game … I hope.
22 pts on 7 shots is fairly decent efficiency.
Knox still has major flaws but he’s slowly winning me over and giving me some hope for his future.
yeah that will paper over some flaws
The kids outplaying the vets we signed.
i guess it IS possible to be too hot
Did that bounce in off Knox or Taj?
Great layup by Kevin on the other end. No way he makes that shot last year.
Knox is so good he even scores for the Nets!
Knicks 70% from three? How long can it last?
Yeah, Randle hacked him. Bad challenge by Fiz.
Yeah, Knox seems to be able to absorb a tiny bit more contact….
Knox is 4-4 from 3 today. He was 3-4 on Wednesday.
KK is OK !
Randle is killin us
Barrett’s free throws….
It’s a good thing RJ is good a lot of things because he’s not going to turn into a shooter.
Randle continues to look as terrible as he did in the preseason. He played well last game, but oof…
Pretty high number of dumb fouls per minute for each team. Yet, a strangely entertaining sloppy game.
Same. He really could be a solid stretch 4.
Morris is so fucking dumb
great job by knox calling for the randle mismatch
Not a good decision by Morris
You mean the guy who’s 2 for 4 from 3?
The reffing is so different this year. Better I think. Morris never would have been hit with that foul last year….
It was, wasn’t it? Kid’s learning a little bit.
KI coming up small!
Make it Wayne!
Barrett went right!!!!
RJ! Our PG!
Nets falling apart!
SICK STEAL AND RIGHT HANDED LAYUP BY RJB, AND ONE!
I laughed more than I should have at this…
Maybe we didn’t need that floater…
Nice job there by Morris forcing the travel
Feel like we aren’t going to go 17 for 25 from 3 every night… Could be wrong…
oooh that could have been a tech
can’t believe that wasn’t a tech
Ellington is GOD
Not gonna lie I jumped out of my chair with excitement after RJ’s And1
Wow what a game all of a sudden. Just keep Randle away from the ball!
Man I’m getting irrationally attached to Barrett already, someone help me. Wayne with the HUGE 3s too, Morris with great defense, damn. Julius needs to step it up.
Unlike last year, I can’t really root for a loss.
Damn that wasn’t even bad defense by RJ
terrible step back 3 by morris on prior possession
Damn the Law of Averages!
Put in trier
I’d rather have gotten blown out than lose like this…
Kyrie wouldn’t have got off as good a 3 with Frank on him there.
Can Fiz draw up a play?
I can’t stand randle or fiz
Randle’s been a disaster down the stretch. Feeding him when everything else was working is kind of vintage Fizdale.
Randle is not winning me over
Randle turns it over way too much
Gotta at least get a shot up there
Game turned out much more entertaining than I would have guessed at halftime.
Only play Knicks know how to run is Ellington off screens, when that doesn’t work its hero ball.
Oh fuck Randle, can’t turn it over like that… damn, this one will hurt.
Bad game for Randle. I hope this is an outlier game.
Anyone a little worried about Barrett’s free throw percentage?
wtf was that?
That was a pitiful ending to a good game.
What was Ellington doing there? Driving when down 4?
well it’s a road loss against a pretty good team, so whatever.
Gave it away
Man, in crunch time every play was iso ball. If Fiz has no clue how to do team offense, maybe that’s why he always chooses offense in his line up choices.
Wow, 17/25 from three and lose.
it’s gonna be hard to trade chris paul when he’s leading his team to a wizards L despite beal shooting 7-22
Why wasn’t trier in there for that play that randle coughed up?
Dumb finish ….
The Knicks look really sloppy. If they didn’t hit 70% of their threes it would have stayed a blowout.
Randle looks terrible out there. I’m not sure what he did different in LA or NO, but Randle needs to start playing better.
The closing lineup makes more sense for playing alongside RJ. You have players who can spread the floor and two players, in Randle and Morris, who should in theory take their man off the dribble.
I really hate any rotation that requires Portis to be out there without a rim protector at center.
We almost won the 2 first games but lost both by amateur closings….
It’s tough in today’s NBA to try to win games without guards who can handle the ball. Knicks trying to win games down the stretch with all forwards handling the ball is a recipe for disaster.
30 missed FGA+TO between Randle and Barrett. It’s like this team is literally built and coached to derp away games where it goes 70% from 3.
So…R. J. looks like he could be kind of special.
Knicks went scoreless almost 4 minutes to close the game. It might have been nice to have that timeout that Fizdale used on the failed challenge. Don’t be surprised if RJ and Trier are the starting backcourt tomorrow night.
Despite sucking hard in both O & D we manage to find a way to have a chance to win.
That’s the only +
Alan and Wally saying “they’re close.”
I’m pretty impressed with RJ’s defense. He was advertised as a bad defender but he competes and stays with his man, and is looking to disrupt plays. He’s not a shitty defender, so that’s a big plus.
Good thing the Knicks picked up DS Jr and Frank’s options….
RJ has 8 steals two games into the season.
That will play with his solid effort out there on defense.
not a bad loss either tonight…. scratched and clawed to make it competive…
we probably wont ever have a better night from 3 for the rest of the season….
WE RE HIRING
RJ has more steals through 2 games than I expected over the first 10.
I though the guy was gonna be a bum, but looks like I was dead wrong. No great shakes on defense but fairly solid, no dumb over reaches that I remember.
I’d like to see RJ do a little more playmaking, but it’s early days. So far he’s been better than I expected.
I think RJ has to be the primary ball handler. He’s already on another level than the rest of the guards, even though he’s 19 and a work in progress. Idk who plays the other guard spot, but hopefully someone who can close out on threes and shoot.
We can’t really blame Randle for the TOs and occasional bad choices. He’s more of a 3rd option being asked to be the primary option in an incoherent offense run by an incompetent coach.
Knox has been good from 3 over the first two games. We can live with bad defense as long as he’s good on offense and only coming off the bench. If he can get that far, it would be a major leap given how terrible he was last year on both ends.
The only real disappointment for me (other than Fizdale) was Payton. The question marks on him are defense and shooting. He was such a pest on defense in the opener I was getting encouraged. But he was weak on defense tonight. He probably still deserves the starting job, but it’s less clear if he can’t or doesn’t want to put out the energy to defend.
I might trade DSJr straight up for Mudiay if I could. lol I’d at least think about it.
Smith needs to go down to the G-League and work on his shot- it wasn’t a thing of beauty last year by any means but it’s flat out busted now.
He’s done okay in that role, but in traditional PG terms Payton is still better. That could change! Payton is a solid backup 1 but he’s not a good starting 1. I think best is to move forward like tonight: Payton starts, the other guys get some backup minutes depending on play, and RJB gets some amount of time based on how it’s going. It’s the second game, this all needs to play out some more.
The problem is Fizdale, management, and probably the pressure of playing in NY.
Smith was bad his first 2 years. Dallas put him on the market and couldn’t give him away. The whole league knew he was bad. Knicks management likes athletic scorers. They were probably impressed by his ability to jump and make the occasional highlight play. They are idiots, but that’s a given.
However, now that we are here, we can’t keep doing this same crap every year where we bring in another mediocre young PG, have them all compete, and yank them as soon as they make a bad play or have a bad game. If I was trying to be a basketball terrorist that would be my strategy. We totally annihilated Frank’s development that way and now we are doing the same thing to Smith this year (and Frank again after he made great progress for France with competent coaching) .
You have to give young players roles based on merit (which in Fizdale’s case is a major problem to begin with because he has no idea who his best players are or how to fit them together) and then stick with them so they are relaxed, comfortable, and can grow into the job. If they fail after a reasonable amount of time and/or the backup is obviously better, you can make a change after awhile and then stick with that.
But this in/out of the doghouse nonsense, 2 TOs and you destroy everything that was accomplished in Europe, busting DSJr out of the rotation altogether now because he missed some shots, making Trier the starter, etc.. is flat out idiocy. Besides being bad, Fizdale is also destroying Smith’s confidence and terrorizing him. Smith knows going in if he misses a few shots or turns the ball over he’s out. No one can or should ever have to play like that.
It is utter coaching malpractice to be up 3 points with a minute to go with 2 time outs and not go Offense/defense substitutions leaving your best 2 defenders on the bench and ESPECIALLY because you KNEW Kyrie was going to shoot the dam ball.
Fizdale is a worse flim flam man than Robert Preston in the Music Man!
They only give lip service to defense. They do not value defense anywhere near its intrinsic value to winning basketball games. That’s why we never get anywhere. Good defense matters a LOT. Great defense wins ball games and helps create better offense. They keep acquiring and playing scorers that can’t defend and then expect a team with 3-4 weak links in every lineup to actually defend well because they are talking about it. We only have a handful of guys that can contribute on both sides or defend at a high level. None of them have major roles except Robinson and he’s so raw he fouls himself out of minutes a lot of the time.
While I don’t disagree about the offense/defense thing, I’m almost more put off by how there just doesn’t seem to be any plan out there in the closing minutes. What is Fizdale even doing?
Yeah, but Barrett had been doing a decent job against Irving to that point and Frank was cold. And Mitch was fouling as often as not against Irving drives. I’m less concerned about this defense centured around disrupting passes and creating turnovers as I am the offense where there the plan was to isolate a turnover prone Randle underneath in a halfcourt set. Trier was hot as shit, at least run him out as an option! Randle is obviously solid in the flow but he’s equally obviously bad in the iso post game. You’re down 2 with ten left, Trier Barrett and Ellenson need to be on the floor with Mitch and Morris, last as a distraction.
The Nets only scored 7 points in the last 3:45 and two of those were on an intentional foul. Offense was the problem. Trier probably should have gone back in given that whatever offense they were running wasn’t generating quality looks. Randle was so bad that swapping him out for Mitch and trying to run pnr’s down the stretch almost certainly would have produced a better result but Randle was brought here to be the focal point of the offense so I think that as early in the season as it is you need to see what you have in him down the stretch in close games.
This team isn’t nearly as bad as last year’s team but they still have little to no margin for error- they’re going to have to do everything right to get wins against decent teams and that wasn’t the case tonight.
I meant just mixing things up on offense/defense period, during all of the stoppages in time (like maybe bring Trier in for offense on the offensive possessions). I agree that it would have been weird to put Frank in cold at that point (although, the argument would be then “Why not try Frank earlier, so he wouldn’t be cold later?”).
That’s fair, but when you’re chasing points Frank ain’t your go to guy. But yeah, a little finesse in the possessions would have been welcome. Was Fiz alergic to that in Memphis as well? But, game two. Staying with the squad that erased the deficit isn’t the worst long term play there.
I’m holding judgement until we play a few more contests, but this turnover chasing defense I don’t hate. It’s fun even if it’s not effective and it seems like the sort of thing that’ll improve going forward. Transition offense looks solid, half court seems like a lot of the old motion shit that isn’t that effective. There were some kick out flashes and some ‘build a lane’ drive plays, but it’s unconvincing.
I’m team realist, but I’m holding out hope that last year’s shit was more personnel than coach.
Looking around the NBA, man, it’s shocking just how many holes there are out there on so many teams. The Jazz are voluntarily starting Jeff Green. The Lakers were relying on Troy Daniels last night. For a league that is filled with so much talent, the salary cap has really led to a weird situation where the mid-level guys just don’t have jobs any more and teams are just saying, “Eh, we’ll just fill things out with minimum pay players.”