Categories
Uncategorized

Knicks Morning News (2025.09.06)

  • New York Knicks Stars Look to Crack Hall of Fame’s Inner Circle – Sports Illustrated

    09/06/2025 11:00:03
     
  • Carmelo Anthony on his playing days with the Knicks: ‘I understood the people’ – HoopsHype

    09/06/2025 09:04:54
     
  • ‘Mutual interest’ between Knicks, free agent former All-Star, says insider – sportingnews.com

    09/06/2025 07:58:23
     
  • Pablo Torre Says He Could Potentially Look Into Jalen Brunson’s New York Knicks Contract – 102.5 The Block

    09/06/2025 05:49:14
     
  • Seth Curry Signing With The New York Knicks – TWSN Sports

    09/06/2025 03:50:13
     
  • Carmelo Anthony ready to be ‘brought in by the basketball gods’ as Hall of Fame beckons – New York Post

    09/06/2025 02:37:00
     
  • Carmelo Anthony enters Hall of Fame embracing Syracuse, Knicks legacy – MassLive

    09/05/2025 23:00:00
     

    • 10 replies on “Knicks Morning News (2025.09.06)”

    Weird weekend to be a Knicks fan. Melo is an obvious hall of famer, but his tenure as our “superstar” was so frustrating from beginning to end that it’s hard to feel all that excited about his induction.

    (Though I’ve encountered a lot of Knicks fans who are younger, where he was the first star of the team they knew, and they love him pretty much unconditionally.)

    I’m not young and i like Melo, Alan. I think he deserves it, and although things didn’t go as we hoped when he was around, he was hardly the only one to blame, Walsh had his share and Dolan had his own (huge) share too. Maybe Melo with the steady kind of management we have now would fare a lot better. But all in all, congrats to him, i still like those years, it’s certainly better than being at the bottom of the league getting picks from 6 to 10.

    Fair enough, cyber. I still can’t entirely forgive him, insisting on being traded at the deadline, rather than waiting for free agency, because that was the original sin. Even if the front office was to blame for almost everything else, but he also refused to play power forward when that was obviously his best position, and I just didn’t really like watching his style of play

    1

    I’m ok with Melo but I feel no kinship to him at all. I don’t even think of him as a Knick. He’s just Melo, and he was here.

    I never fully forgave Melo for pushing for a trade and the Knicks having to give up Gallinari for him. As far as I am concerned, Melo had way more skill than Gallo, but at his best, Gallo contributed almost as much value to winning as Melo. Gallo was a much smarter player and got more out of his skill with higher efficiency. He’ll just never the credit he deserves and Melo will almost get more than he deserves because he scored more in volume.

    1

    I find it hard to get excited about Me7o in the HOF. I am not particularly partial to low efficiency (TS% .546) high volume (31.7 USG%) chuckers who are allergic to defense (-1.1 DBPM) who forced his way to NY via trade which sacrificed the exact complimentary players and future assets he needed to succeed.

    In addition his “style” of play drove 2 pretty fair coaches George Karl and Pringles (who had a 350 and 150 games over .500 career NBA coaching records respectfully) completely bat shit insane. Also his conduct (I’m not sharing the spotlight with an Asian) during Linsanity was pretty reprehensible.

    After watching HOF players like Clyde, Willis and Dave D sublimate their individual skills for the good of the whole and group success, it is hard to admire a selfish, inefficient player like Anthony.

    1

    Amar’e only had like 3 good months here, but I like him so much more. His 30 point game streak reignited the Garden and my passion for basketball. I’ll never forget the game winning block he had against the Bobcats; it came the night before Thanksgiving and the next day I made everyone at my table thank him for coming to NY. Sometime around Christmas I asked my girlfriend if it was ok if we named our firstborn Amar’e, and I argued it would be equally appropriate for a boy or a girl. And as I remember it, he hit a game-winning buzzer beater at the Garden to shut up Paul Pierce and the Celtics. I know it was waived off because it came after the buzzer, but for ten seconds I didn’t know that because I was running around the Village Pourhouse like a lunatic hi-fiving a hundred other delirious Knicks fans, and I’ll always have those ten seconds.

    I don’t have as many fond Melo memories, and he played so much longer than Amar’e. Game 2 in Boston his first year when he scored 42 points and almost single-handedly beat Pierce, Garnett, Allen, and Rondo was probably my favorite, because for one night I thought maybe he really is that good. There was an Easter Sunday game against the DRose/Thibodeau Bulls that blew my mind, I remember that. And he had that great game against the Heat in the playoffs but it was somewhat muted by the fact that we were down 3-0.

    But he was very hard to embrace bc like Alan said he ripped the heart out of our team. And it was always his ego. Whether it was the arrogance that made him think we didn’t need the supporting players and draft picks it took to acquire him, the fragility that made him shade Lin and contribute to his departure, or just the game-to-game “I’m taking every shot down the stretch” which led to predictably terrible results, it was always so much ego with him. And it wasn’t fun.

    Even his one good team disintegrated in the playoffs in large part because of his ego. He single-handedly killed the two-PG, move-the-ball, bomb-from-3 style of play that was so effective because in his mind it was the playoffs so that meant he had to take every shot.

    RIP Davey Johnson, who I liked a lot despite his moustache, and who had an inexplicable 43 homers one season back in the day.

    And I’m with Team Melo Who.

    Leave a Reply

    This site uses User Verification plugin to reduce spam. See how your comment data is processed.