Knicks 99, Sixers 93

Philadelphia 76ers 93 FinalRecap | Box Score 99 New York Knicks
Carmelo Anthony, SF 40 MIN | 6-18 FG | 16-18 FT | 7 REB | 2 AST | 0 STL | 0 BLK | 5 TO | 29 PTS | -14Another day, another 40+ minute game, but at least this one was a win.Anthony looked really good tonight in spite of the fact that his perimeter shot still wasn’t working. He was super-aggressive and made quick decisions on his post-ups, spinning and winning and grinning his way to 18 free throw attempts. This aggression led to a number of turnovers and Sixer run-outs, but overall, Anthony played did about the best he could to help the team win.

The oddity of Anthony’s box score numbers is that he was -14 on the game. However, this can largely be attributed to the fact that Anthony played most of his minutes with Shumpert and Kidd, who continued their awful play, rather than J.R. Smith and Amar’e Stoudemire, who were the MVPs of this game.

The one boneheaded decision by Anthony was his decision to slap Spencer Hawes in the back of the head after he Hawes had blocked him. Not only did it bring back memories of the famous “Carmelo slap and run” (I didn’t make up that name; google suggested I add the “and run” to the end of my search for “carmelo anthony slap”), but it also led to Tyson Chandler picking up his tenth tech of the season, only six short of a suspension.

Tyson Chandler, C 35 MIN | 2-2 FG | 1-3 FT | 12 REB | 1 AST | 0 STL | 3 BLK | 2 TO | 5 PTS | +14Chandler took only two shots in 35 minutes as the Sixer defense repeatedly ignored Shumpert and Kidd in order to prevent Chandler from catching any lobs. In fact, both of Chandler’s field goals were put back dunks. He didn’t take a single shot within the offense.The difference between Chandler and Stoudemire’s offenses was put on display tonight, as Stoudemire’s ability and willingness to find shot opportunities off catches outside the restricted area resulted in a huge scoring night for him, whereas Chandler passed out on most of his paint catches.

Still, Chandler played some tough defense, blocking three shots (including a man-sized block of a Hawes hook shot early on), and his four offensive rebounds led to six points — what ended up being the margin of the game.

Jason Kidd, PG 26 MIN | 1-7 FG | 1-2 FT | 9 REB | 2 AST | 1 STL | 0 BLK | 2 TO | 3 PTS | -9He also only had one basket, a wide open layup on a nearly botched four on two, in seven tries. His other six attempts were all threes, and most of them weren’t very close (although not as far of as some of Felton’s tries). He does deserve kudos for nearly making a three late in the game, on an attempt wherein he probably could have blown one of his trademark kisses to the rim before shooting. He also had nine rebounds, so that’s good, I guess.There’s really not much more to say about Kidd. At least he took the shots the SIxers were giving him, unlike on some other nights. The guy is old, and after a renaissance of a couple years over in Dallas, he’s been in decline for years, so while it’s fair to be disappointed with his shooting, it’s not really fair to be surprised.

It might be time for Kidd to spend some time away from basketball and over on Clyde’s island in St. Croix. Maybe then he can play in the playoffs as he did in the first month of the season.

Raymond Felton, PG 36 MIN | 6-15 FG | 0-0 FT | 0 REB | 4 AST | 1 STL | 0 BLK | 0 TO | 14 PTS | -9Raymond was slightly better than he has been of late. He took the ball in the paint and finished relatively well, especially early on, and he took care of the ball. Like Kidd, he took the perimeter shots the defense gave him, and also like Kidd (although not as bad), he missed the bulk of them. He would have had several more assists if only Kidd and Shumpert made their open shots.In the end, the Sixer defense (what there was of it) marginalized Felton by taking away the pick and roll, going under most screens and cluttering the paint, forcing the Knicks to rely on Carmelo post ups, off of which Felton is just not a great option due to his ho-hum perimeter game.
Iman Shumpert, PG 13 MIN | 1-5 FG | 1-1 FT | 2 REB | 1 AST | 1 STL | 0 BLK | 1 TO | 4 PTS | 0This was Shumpert’s 16th game of the season, and the Knicks are now 2-5 in games where he’s played over 20 minutes, and 7-2 in games where he’s played under 20.Iman hasn’t been Iman on either end of the floor but especially on offense. Yes, he had a nice play, forcing a Holiday turnover early in the first, but he was also beaten backdoor by Jrue on at least two occasions. On offense, the Sixers mostly acted as though he wasn’t there, and Iman seemed to agree with them.

My take on Iman is that he’s maybe going through a bit of an identity crisis here. He’s made his living as a defensive player, and because of his stellar defense, coaches have been able to forgive his freewheeling (the nice way of putting it) offense. His defense is still good, but it’s not at the level it was last year. He can’t hang his hat on it, so to speak, and so he’s left to wonder who he is as a basketball player, and that self-doubt only compounds the problems. (/armchair psychology)

It’s time for Shumpert to go to the bench. Not only will it take pressure off of him, but after last summer, when the Knicks offseason signings (and non signings) made it clear that it was now or never for a championship run, now is just not the time to be trying to develop a guy who is coming back from an injury from which it can take years to fully recover. Add to that that a bench role would take some pressure off in terms of media attention and level of compettition, so it might be a quicker path to recovery.

Amar’e Stoudemire, PF 22 MIN | 9-10 FG | 4-6 FT | 5 REB | 0 AST | 2 STL | 0 BLK | 1 TO | 22 PTS | +1022 points in 22 minutes on 9-10 shooting. I know you can read those stats just above this text, but I thought you should read them again. Stoudemire was huge tonight, and for once, the +/- numbers, which haven’t been so kind to Stoudemire this season, bare it out. Stoudemire was +10 on the game, second only to Chandler among those who played over 20 minutes. If you exclude the minutes he shared the floor with Anthony and just look at those during which he was the primary option on offense, Stoudemire was +20 in only EIGHT MINUTES!!!”That’s sick!” you’re saying under your breath right now, and I agree with you.

Yes, the Sixers were slow on defense having played in Philly one night earlier, and yes, they also saved Thaddeus Young, who gave Stoudemire a lot of trouble last year, to defend Anthony (god knows why since he seemed to bite on every Anthony head fake), but this was a magical night for STAT nonetheless.

Steve Novak, SF 19 MIN | 1-2 FG | 1-1 FT | 6 REB | 0 AST | 1 STL | 0 BLK | 0 TO | 4 PTS | +20Steve Novak played the most non-blowout minutes since early January.Steve Novak only took two shots in those minutes.

Steve Novak had the highest +/- on the team.

Yeah, he rode Stoudemire’s coattails, but you could also argue a big part of Stoudemire’s huge night was the fact that with Novak as his running mate, the paint was overflowing with red and white. Teams have to guard Novak, which is more than can be said for several other players in the Knick rotation.

Pablo Prigioni, PG 13 MIN | 1-4 FG | 2-2 FT | 1 REB | 5 AST | 0 STL | 0 BLK | 0 TO | 4 PTS | +13Prigioni’s was serviceable tonight. The Holiday matchup kept his minutes down, but he and Stoudemire continued to exhibit the chemistry that we first saw in the preseason. He too couldn’t make a shot, except for the one where he was sort of cowboy kicking to his left and tossed it towards the basket as the shot clock was expiring. That was nice.
J.R. Smith, SG 36 MIN | 5-12 FG | 1-2 FT | 6 REB | 2 AST | 1 STL | 0 BLK | 1 TO | 14 PTS | +5Smith saved this game. His stats don’t suggest a wonderful performance, but the three consecutive fourth quarter threes stymied a Sixer run and just about sealed the victory. What was more remarkable about Smith’s performance though was the energy he played with on defense.Smith stopped a layup by Jeremy Pargo with a chase down block; his ball pressure and then deflection on Evans early in the fourth led to a Knick runout and kept the lead in double digits; and his offensive rebound after the Sixers had cut it to five with a minute left, were all huge plays that could not have happened if not for J.R. playing in turbo mode for most of the not.

Smith’s early season defense was a huge part of the team’s early run. He’s one of the only players the Knicks have who can cover ground quickly, making him crucial if the Knicks ever hope to control penetration (something they didn’t do all that well tonight, but still).

Kenyon Martin, PF DNP COACH’S DECISION MIN | FG | FT | REB | AST | STL | BLK | TO | PTS | I enjoyed watching Kenyon laugh as Spencer Hawes and Tyson Chandler went after each other.
Mike WoodsonWhy did Woodson take Stoudemire out after his fifth foul? He was dominating, and odds were he wasn’t going to get back in the game anyway (he didn’t). Just a thoughtless decision that could have cost the Knicks the game. Also, again, Anthony plays 40+ minutes. If he’d kept STAT in for two more minutes, the Knicks quite possibly would have been up twenty, and Melo would have played 32 minutes instead of 40.This game didn’t offer Woodson too many chances to mess things up, but Woodson is just a bad in-game coach. In fact, he’s a bad between game coach, too, but that’s for an entire article. He seems pretty good at motivating guys, but he has no ability to think outside the box.

Five Things We Saw

  1. Spiro Dedes, who has a beautiful voice and a lovely goattee, took the shoving match between Chandler and Hawes as a chance to blah blah blah for about ten minutes about how Chandler’s decision showed the Knicks had fight and toughness and were going to turn things around. Blah. Blech.The Knicks are a saucy team. Especially recently, they seem to cherish the opportunity for the sideshow garbage, whining to officials, talking trash to other players… Some guys know how to use this stuff as motivation, but outside of Sheed, who can trash talk all he wants in my book, the Knicks’ trash talk often seems born out of bogus machismo. It’s not a game wherein they’re trying to play the officials for calls or get into their opponents’ heads. For them, their manly pridefulness is more important than winning basketball games, and when it’s challenged, their focus shifts to defending it rather than defending the rim or taking smart shots. Rather than winning. Maybe they choose that that path because it’s easier to win a barking match (or at least to feel as though you’ve won) than to win a basketball game.So Spiro, I respectfully disagree with you and your goattee. The Knicks could use some training at the Tim Duncan school of basketball. You win these fights by unsubscribing from them and leaving your opponent feeling helpless and childish.
  2. For a game between two of the slower paced teams in the league, this sure was a fast paced game. My quick and probably incorrect calculation puts the pace at 106, about sixteen possessions faster than the Knicks and Sixers average. It seemed to work to New York’s advantage, too. When they were scoring well, it seemed to usually come off a miss and a push, with the team getting it to Stoudemire or Melo for a quick score before the Philly defense could set.This may have only been effective due to the Sixers’ tired legs, but it’s worth exploring given how challenging scoring has been for New York against the better defensive teams.
  3. This win was nice as it broke the losing streak, and there were certainly some positive signs, but to put it in context, the Knicks were home. They were playing a team on the second night of a home/away back to back. They were playing a team that had lost four in a row and was nine games under .500. They only won by six points. If this was November, we would have called this win ominous.
  4. The Knicks continue to give up easy shots in the paint at an alarming rate. The Sixers had 36 FGAs in the paint. The Knicks were simply fortunate that they only made 44% on those shots, a number that is completely unsustainable, especially against better offenses. We also continued to see open threes, but again Philly mostly failed to capitalize. There were streaks were the Knick D truly was stifling, especially late in the 3rd and early in the 4th, but that can be said of just about any team. The sum total of your performance is what matters.
  5. Tonight’s game was not unlike the Knicks performance over the last couple months. They had streaks of great play, but they did not play consistently, and with a team made up of so many role players — guy’s with no ability to freelance on a broken play or cover for a bad rotation — execution is critical to the team’s success. However, unlike the past couple weeks, at least tonight’s game was a win. Maybe that psychological boost will lead them to extend the good play across more than 5-10 minute stretches. Also, hopefully Kidd gets his shot back, because without that, this team will never be more than just above average.
Liked it? Take a second to support max fisher-cohen on Patreon!

max fisher-cohen

In addition to writing for Knickerblogger, Max teaches English at Tallahassee Community College and writes short stories. He recently finished a feature screenplay, and he is working right now to raise the funds to film it. You can check it out on Kickstarter.

12 thoughts to “Knicks 99, Sixers 93”

  1. Thanks for the recap, Max, but I disagree with a couple of the ratings. Kidd had 9 rebounds in 26 minutes and while he was 1-7, he took shots that he was supposed to take (as opposed to the end of the game vs. Toronto). Also think that Amare was rated too high, he was outrebounded on a number of occasions (Novak and Kidd had more rebounds than him) and slow on a number of defensive rotations.

  2. GOOD POINTS “Z-MAN” (below)

    if we had a PG who get to the rim/take a mid ranger such as JWin last year … And put the ball into Chandlers hands too shoot more … It would take pressure off of Anthony/Novak and I’m sorry JR gotta go!!!! ..And Kenyon Martian are you kidding me????

    Who we really need to pick up for defensive measures & a shot or two is Josh Harrelson

    Knicks NEED TO SiGN BIGJORTS!!!!
    WTF Kenyon Martin

    Thanks for the recap, Max, but I disagree with a couple of the ratings. Kidd had 9 rebounds in 26 minutes and while he was 1-7, he took shots that he was supposed to take (as opposed to the end of the game vs. Toronto). Also think that Amare was rated too high, he was outrebounded on a number of occasions (Novak and Kidd had more rebounds than him) and slow on a number of defensive rotations.

  3. February and March are something of the NBA’s “dog days”. I don’t want to make excuses for stretches of poor play, but the tenor here seems a tad harsh. This team just wasn’t built to lay waste to the regular season.

    My big concern right now is actually with Chandler’s minutes rather than Melo’s. My expectation was that neither Sheed nor Camby would play a lot this season. My *hope* was that we could keep one or the other healthy enough to keep Chandler in the 30-32 mpg area. As it is, NY is only giving up 1.5 pts/100 poss more than Miami. (Their relative def rating rankings–18th vs 11th–suggest a much wider disparity.) What worries me is that he’s the glue holding it together. He’s gotta be right in the spring for us to have a shot.

  4. Re: the paint defense – I actually thought it was pretty good. They took a bunch of shot attempts there but most of them were highly contested by one Tyson Chandler. Tyson has been playing MUCH better defensively of late – especially with his contesting of shots. He has 8 blocks in the last 2 games (as many as he had in the previous 8 games combined), and I would guess that he has altered many more.

    RE: this win – I think the margin of victory is pretty misleading. Philly never got within 1 possession, and we were up by 8-12 for almost the entire second half. Sure, it would’ve been nice to put the game away with a couple Novak daggers, but I literally was never worried.

    Re: Shump – totally agree that he looks lost out there. He literally is playing with zero swag right now, which is just so different from last year. Even his jumper form looks tentative, like he’s already expecting to be running back on D after a long rebound.

    btw love how we were running in the first half – not so much the second. Not sure why all teams don’t run it up the floor on most possessions, if only to get 3-4 more seconds to get a good shot.

  5. Nice write-up, analysis, observations and insights such as they are. I read this on the phone coming in and it seems in the intervening hours the grades changed. am I misremembering?

  6. David Crockett: My big concern right now is actually with Chandler’s minutes rather than Melo’s. … He’s gotta be right in the spring for us to have a shot.

    totally agree – the last few games and also that stretch of 20 rebound games shows how great Tyson can be when he gives 100% effort. It’s just so painfully obvious when he’s taking plays or even whole games off.

    Also agree that we need to take a breath before condemning this team to the 6 seed or worse. Maybe that’ll happen, and certainly the schedule will not do us any favors, but we do have to remember we probably have had the worst injury problems in the league. If you look at all the real contenders (for argument’s sake I’ll say Miami, Indiana, Chicago, OKC, San Antonio, and the Clips) — none of them have had injury issues like us. Sure, Indiana has missed Granger the whole year, and Chicago hasn’t had Rose, but as many others have said, it’s a totally different thing to have a guy out from the beginning than to have created a chemistry and system that relies on a guy then have that guy taken away by injury. And even so, Indiana was very average in the beginning of the year until they sort of got it together the last month+. The Clips were horrible without CP3. And Miami never seems to have injuries for some reason (hmm…Miami, the new center of PED universe… hmmm.). We’ve had to shuttle in guys in and out based on injuries, find new lineups/chemistry, etc.

    Anyway, I think we will have enough to take the Atlantic, and hopefully we will have 2 of K-Mart, Sheed, and Camby healthy for the stretch run (late March to end of season) so Woody can find the optimal units to run out there, and so those units can really develop chemistry and communication.

    btw Woody deserves some credit for rejiggering the subs so that Tyson plays with Amare in the 2nd Q. Much better.

  7. Hey all, long time reader, first time poster, Knick fan since i was old enough to appreciate having my heart stop with every questionable Starks jumper (Oh, hey JR, what’s up? I know you’ll break my heart, but i still love you).

    I really hope this is the second act on the typical hollywood narrative that someone mentioned yesterday, but as long as i’ve been alive the knicks have never lived that script, tragedy is our specialty people.

    The difference this season is that it will be meaningful in a way it hasn’t been for over a decade. As flawed as this team is, it has a tiny, improbable chance at the title. And when we inevitably, heartbreakingly and likely disgracefully bow out, I’ll thank and applaud this team and coach for making NY basketball worth suffering for again.

    That being said, and i love the man, Novak has no business playing meaningful minutes. Every single opposing coach attacks him on defense, and you can see all of our defenders nervously cheating of their man to bail Novak out. A B Grade for 3 points on two shots on 20 minutes seems egregious. I get that we have no outside shooters other than melo and JR and Woody’s hand is forced to an extent, but watching that man on the court is embarrassing, plus-minus be damned.

  8. I think the way we come out of March will be determined by the next 7 games. You can chalk up losses to the Heat and the Thunder, but we need to somehow win the other 5 – GS, Wash., Cleve. Det. Utah. Then we can afford some slippage on the 5 game west coast trip.

  9. I’m really eager to see how K-mart and Amar’e play together. STAT absolutely cannot anchor the defense, but with another plus defender in the frontcourt who can quarterback the D (for example when playing with Chandler last night), he becomes SO much less of a liability and can really do some damage on the other end, particularly when he’s put there with at least a couple guys who can actually shoot. Same applies to Camby and Sheed, but who knows when they’ll be back.

    Kidd and Shumoert need their minutes cut in the worst way. I’m okay with Novak in at SF when Amar’e and another big are on the floor. I am not okay with Novak at PF, ever.

  10. Knicks still lead the 3point FGM due to the spectacular start of the season. But this slide towards under 10 3pFGM/game has to end..right?

    Knicks 3FG% 3FGA/FGA
    nov. ….. 41,6 34,6
    dec. …. 37,1 34,7
    jan. ….. 36,0 34,5
    feb. ….. 33,7 38,0

    Reasons? better defenses or are Knicks just tired. I’m afraid the legs are just not that fresh any more. Rest’n’tank I would.

  11. @Dave Crockett I get 2-3 week period of mediocrity followed by a few statement games, but the knicks haven’t had a truly impressive performance since December. I just don’t see this as the midseason blues.

    @Z-Man Kidd played hard but we would have lost this game by 20 (a true embarrassment) with 48 minutes of our starting lineup. Philly completely ignored both Kidd and Shumpert, and if not for a dominating performance by Amar’e, this would have been a loss, so yeah, Kidd got rebounds and Amar’e didn’t, but Amar’e was the MAN in this game nonetheless as far as how he affected the outcome.

    Kidd, on the other hand, despite a good effort on the boards, was still a huge burden. I could see a D but nothing higher.

    @Nick, I didn’t change the grades, nor did I fix the typos or the way wordpress screwed up my line breaks. Oh well.

  12. i find the desire to “bench” shumpert confusing. first of all, this is the time to be working out the kinks and finding one’s game. its not the playoffs. secondly, who is the heck do you suggest take Shump’s minutes or starting spot? I know its not Kidd. It cant possibly be Novak. Amare could move melo to the 4, but history has shown that Amare’s knees cant take huge minutes. Also, for all of the “game MVP” talk for amare, his defense/ rebounding both last night and historically is awful. So, we come to JR. Remember, he is JR smith, so putting any eggs in the basket is just asking to be dissapointed in the end. And JR played 36 minutes!!!! Someone has to play to 2 and the 3. Thats 96 minutes of basketball. If JR gets 35 (which is a stretch) and Kidd gets 20 (which he shouldnt at this point), that still leaves over 40 minutes of playing time. Someone needs to play that position, and shump should be getting the majority of the time. people should be as patient with shump as they have been with amare, melo (last year), and kidd. Shump is the one player who could actually improve by the playoffs and close the gap between us and the Heat at least a little

Comments are closed.