Game Thread: Knicks vs. Magic

January 30th, 2013 by | @JPCavan | Comments | Permalink |

The Knicks try and make it two in a row against Orlando, who hopefully partied late into the night last night.

Beyond his work for KnickerBlogger, Jim is a contributor to the New York Times Off the Dribble NBA blog, ESPN.com, and The Classical. He is currently working on a biography of Robert Silverman, titled "Clownin' and Astoundin.'" Follow him on Twitter @JPCavan.

128 Responses to “Game Thread: Knicks vs. Magic”

  1. 1
    jon abbey says:

    SHUMP SHUMP

  2. 2
    johnlocke says:

    Let’s see how we guard the PG position tonight.

  3. 3
    johnlocke says:

    Kenny Albert…unbelievable voice and forehead

  4. 4
    AnonymousODG says:

    Looks like they’re breaking down the defense successfully.

    Also: screw Reddick.

  5. 5
    Owen says:

    Wow reddick….

    Think we should guard him?

  6. 6
    massive says:

    Raymond Felton’s defense is so horrifically bad right now.

  7. 7
    ruruland says:

    massive:
    Raymond Felton’s defense is so horrifically bad right now.

    Uh, Iman Shumpert’s is worse.

  8. 8
    Will the Thrill says:

    Shump can’t stop Reddick at all! Also, his total inability to finish around the rim has always baffled me.

  9. 9
    maxwell_3g says:

    geezus defense!!!! when did we bring dantoni back?

  10. 10
    ruruland says:

    Love to see Chandler playing on offense.

  11. 11
    ruruland says:

    maxwell_3g:
    geezus defense!!!! when did we bring dantoni back?

    A lot of this is absolutely absurd shooting, as much as people won’t want to hear it.

  12. 12
    Will the Thrill says:

    Right now, but the trend of the last few games doesn’t look good for Raymond at all.

    ruruland: Uh, Iman Shumpert’s is worse.

  13. 13
    ruruland says:

    Will the Thrill:
    Right now, but the trend of the last few games doesn’t look good for Raymond at all.

    Yeah, they’ve both been horrible the last 3 games.

    I don’t expect that to last all year. But who knows.

  14. 14
    lavor postell says:

    With Reddick torching us it’s as simple as Woody telling Shumpert not to go over the screen. He’s gotten a wide open look everytime he’s attempted to shoot the passing lane.

  15. 15
    massive says:

    ruruland: Uh, Iman Shumpert’s is worse.

    I saw Shumpert helping out on Nelson after he blew past Felton with ease. Then Nelson passed the ball to Reddick, who nailed a shot on a Shumpert close out. If Felton could actually stay in front of his man (which he can’t), Shumpert wouldn’t look so bad right now.

  16. 16
    d-mar says:

    Shump’s rep as a defensive stopper is being somewhat challenged tonight I would say

  17. 17
    massive says:

    Why does Felton keep giving Nelson his right hand?

  18. 18
    AnonymousODG says:

    Bleh, another defensively poor 1st quarter.

    At least we’re not helplessly throwing up bricks.

  19. 19
    ruruland says:

    massive: I saw Shumpert helping out on Nelson after he blew past Felton with ease. Then Nelson passed the ball to Reddick, who nailed a shot on a Shumpert close out. If Felton could actually stay in front of his man (which he can’t), Shumpert wouldn’t look so bad right now.

    His inability to get around screens is quite unbecoming of a defensive ace. If you actually go back and watch players reaction to his plug on that play, it’s clear he was NOT supposed to come of Reddick.

    As great as Chandler has been offensively, we’ve seen Amar’e chase penetration into the paint more than Chandler did in that first quarter.

  20. 20
    Will the Thrill says:

    Wasn’t Shumpert on Korver last game? Didn’t seem horrible.

    ruruland: Yeah, they’ve both been horrible the last 3 games.

    I don’t expect that to last all year. But who knows.

  21. 21
    ruruland says:

    lavor postell:
    With Reddick torching us it’s as simple as Woody telling Shumpert not to go over the screen.He’s gotten a wide open look everytime he’s attempted to shoot the passing lane.

    It’s quite clear by players reactions that Shumpert was supposed to know this.

  22. 22
    ruruland says:

    Will the Thrill:
    Wasn’t Shumpert on Korver last game? Didn’t seem horrible.

    Yeah, it just seems like Shump’s been involved in a lot of scores.

  23. 23
    Will the Thrill says:

    Ayon, Amar’e's greatest nemesis.

  24. 24
    maxwell_3g says:

    ruru, i like you man, but please stop comparing chandler’s and stat’s defense….. most of us, if not all of us, are really rooting for stat to improve in this area, but there is no comparison to be made

  25. 25
    maxwell_3g says:

    i dont undrstand this defense. how does a guy try to drive by novak, not get by him, but hes able to kick out to ish smith for a 3 with no one in the area code

  26. 26
    d-mar says:

    Orlando now missing their 2 best players, and we still are putting up no resistance on defense. Not good.

  27. 27
    Will the Thrill says:

    Ew Felton, ew.

  28. 28
    ruruland says:

    Nelson is making some really tough shots, too.

  29. 29
    maxwell_3g says:

    our perimeter passing off the drive and off the double team does not seem crisp tonight. maybe its the spacing that is off. but pass are off target, etc. got to tighten up

  30. 30
    ruruland says:

    Paint points: Knicks 28, Orlando 16

  31. 31
    ruruland says:

    maxwell_3g:
    our perimeter passing off the drive and off the double team does not seem crisp tonight.maybe its the spacing that is off.but pass are off target, etc.got to tighten up

    agreed, would also like to see harder drives against rotation.

  32. 32
    maxwell_3g says:

    ruruland:
    Nelson is making some really tough shots, too.

    yeah, nothing felton could have done on that last one. nelon is an interesting player. i dont watch him much, for obvious reasons, and really have no idea how good he really is, beyond his stats. is he better than felton? i could be swayed wither way. he sure looks good tonight

  33. 33
    Will the Thrill says:

    Seems like other teams are deliberately looking to attack Felton haha

  34. 34
    maxwell_3g says:

    the magic backcourt is torching us. imagine Kidd was playing!!

  35. 35
    ruruland says:

    maxwell_3g: yeah, nothing felton could have done on that last one.nelon is an interesting player.i dont watch him much, for obvious reasons, and really have no idea how good he really is, beyond his stats.is he better than felton?i could be swayed wither way.he sure looks good tonight

    he is def. better than Felton, though similar, but a hot/cold player who’s best games are much better than Felton’s.

    Not much different defensively, Felton might be a better penetrator/passer/

  36. 36
    Thomas B. says:

    If you’ve ever wondered what an All-Star game would be like if none of the stars showed up, this is your game.

  37. 37
    johnlocke says:

    Chandlers help defense has been nonexistent for some time now…blocking shots may be slightly overrated and all but when was the last time Chandler had one. His help defense on small penetrating guards is just lazy. He needs to block Ish Smith or Nelson or put the, on their ass. I don’t care about his fouls.

    maxwell_3g:
    ruru, i like you man, but please stop comparing chandler’s and stat’s defense…..most of us, if not all of us, are really rooting for stat to improve in this area, but there is no comparison to be made

  38. 38
    ruruland says:

    Thomas B.:
    If you’ve ever wondered what an All-Star game would be like if none of the stars showed up, this is your game.

    Wow

  39. 39
    Brian Cronin says:

    Well, at least Reddick finally missed! Either of those misses would have been brutal had he connected.

    In better news, come on, folks, there’s no way that the Magic shoot this well in the second half. The Knicks will likely win this one going away.

  40. 40
    ruruland says:

    Wallace doing a nice job on Lebron, who can’t get a whistle. Bird looks great. That’s troubling.

  41. 41
    Brian Cronin says:

    Bird looks great. That’s troubling.

    You got that right. That sucks that he looks good.

  42. 42
    ruruland says:

    Brian Cronin:
    Well, at least Reddick finally missed two shots!

    Right, a lot of this is just two good shooters getting really hot at the same time.

    It’s not exactly a layup line out there.

    16 paint points in a half is actually an elite number, especially when paired with 4 free-throws.

    The Pacers lead the league in paint points allowed per game (35.7).

  43. 43
    ruruland says:

    Brian Cronin: You got that right. That sucks that he looks good.

    He fits their system perfectly, in every single way. Not a good man defender or positional rebounder, but he’s a great weakside/rotation player and one of the best big man runners in the game.

  44. 44
    ephus says:

    Watching from a sports book in Vegas. Glad I hit the money line instead of giving up 9.

  45. 45
    ruruland says:

    I love the shots Chandler’s been taking tonight. When teams double Melo off the ball he has to take that wide open elbow jumper. Absolutely has to.

  46. 46
    ephus says:

    Blatche is showing that he just totally checked out last year. It is a joke that he was on the scrap heap last summer.

  47. 47
    Thomas B. says:

    ruruland: Wow

    What, you think they aren’t playing All-Star Game level defense?

  48. 48
    johnlocke says:

    You said if none of the stars showed up….ahem, Melo

    Thomas B.: What, you think they aren’t playing All-Star Game level defense?

  49. 49
    ephus says:

    And that follow on the air all is why Chandler should not contest 25 feet from the rim.

  50. 50
    maxwell_3g says:

    OK, im not impressed with tyson’s d today either….but, he hs to be one of the 3 best game dunkers in the league right now, right? that dun on the break was pretty ridiculous

  51. 51
    maxwell_3g says:

    time to push this league to double digits

  52. 52
    Thomas B. says:

    johnlocke:
    You said if none of the stars showed up….ahem, Melo

    He did sit for a good portion of the 2nd when the worst of it was going on. I was speaking of that stretch. Plus it doesn’t feel like he’s playing much.

  53. 53
    lavor postell says:

    This is what Miami must have felt like when they played the Knicks without Melo. How many hero shots have Nelson and Reddick hit in this game? J.J. just rose up about 3 feet beyond the arc with Chandler in his face and he drains it. Not much you can do there.

  54. 54
    ephus says:

    Love the d. Stat forced the travel but JR had the key rotation.

  55. 55
    maxwell_3g says:

    hoooo Stat!!!! good explosion at the hoop there

  56. 56
    ephus says:

    I can’t believe Prigioni hit that shot

  57. 57
    maxwell_3g says:

    what is melo doing??? enough of the hero ball!!!!

  58. 58
    ephus says:

    Tonight the heat check failed.

  59. 59
    maxwell_3g says:

    ephus:
    Tonight the heat check failed.

    there was no heat to check. it was just a gunner shot

  60. 60
    ruruland says:

    Chandler and Amar’e 14/15 inside the paint. 29 points, 9 rebounds, 6 assists. That’s a frontcourt.

  61. 61
    Douglas says:

    Prigs with the old man layup!

  62. 62
    DRed says:

    Prigioni is just awesome.

  63. 63
    ephus says:

    Douglas:
    Prigs with the old man layup!

    And he should have gotten the hoop and the harm.

  64. 64
    johnlocke says:

    Good pass by amare

  65. 65
    Thomas B. says:

    ruruland:
    Chandler and Amar’e 14/15 inside the paint. 29 points, 9 rebounds, 6 assists. That’s a frontcourt.

    You have to take advantage of an awful defensive frontcourt when they come to town.

  66. 66
    ephus says:

    Heat are not a strong road team this year. Nets tied at half after being down 10.

  67. 67
    johnlocke says:

    We should have posted amare there

  68. 68
    johnlocke says:

    He’ll yeah!!

  69. 69
    massive says:

    That’s Gustavo Ayon? Good! I remember when he killed us last year during Linsanity.

  70. 70
    Nick C. says:

    Love that drive and dish from Prigioni to Amare.

  71. 71
    Douglas says:

    Pablo with the old man back tap! That made unreasonably happy.

  72. 72
    DRed says:

    Prigs can even rebound like Tyson. I’m really shocked by how good he turned out to be.

    Well, except for that last shot.

  73. 73
    Douglas says:

    …and a very old man three attempt.

  74. 74
    maxwell_3g says:

    Priggy smalls!!!!!

  75. 75
    Douglas says:

    and then he redeems himself!

    It’s the Pablo Prigioni show and we are all merely spectators.

  76. 76
    ephus says:

    Prigioni shows he has no short-term memory. Follows an airball three with a swish three.

  77. 77
    johnlocke says:

    Why we don’t run that Melo amare pnr more I will never know. I’m not sure how you stop that

  78. 78
    ephus says:

    johnlocke:
    Why we don’t run that Melo amare pnr more I will never know. I’m not sure how you stop that

    You stop the Carmelo aMare pick and roll by blitzing it with three men need shooters on the court with them to make it work. That’s why Novak is out there with them.

  79. 79
    Douglas says:

    Nice trap by STAT and JR.

  80. 80
    Douglas says:

    ephus:
    Prigioni shows he has no short-term memory. Follows an airball three with a swish three.

    He’s like a goldfish.

  81. 81
    ephus says:

    Is that Stephanie March on celebrity row?

  82. 82
    johnlocke says:

    That’s my point…that’s not stopping it.

    ephus: You stop the CarmeloaMare pick and roll by blitzing it with three men need shooters on the court with them to make it work. That’s why Novak is out there with them.

  83. 83
    elo says:

    Stat is back!

  84. 84
    DRed says:

    Amare is unconscious tonight. He can play whatever defense he wants as long as he never misses.

  85. 85
    Douglas says:

    And the sneaky backdoor cut for the dish to a wide open Novak. Pablo, I loves ya.

  86. 86
    maxwell_3g says:

    i will say it again. amare is actually trying on defense now, and that is at least half the battle

  87. 87
    DRed says:

    How is Prigs not in the rookie game?

  88. 88
    AnonymousODG says:

    It’s raining 3s.

  89. 89
    Douglas says:

    Floodgates are opening

  90. 90
    maxwell_3g says:

    i am impressed with vucevic

  91. 91
    Douglas says:

    maxwell_3g:
    i will say it again.amare is actually trying on defense now, and that is at least half the battle

    Also half the battle: knowing

    GI JOEEEEEE

  92. 92
    Garson says:

    24 assists on 41Fgm is nice to see. Sharing is caring

  93. 93
    maxwell_3g says:

    Douglas: Also half the battle: knowing

    GI JOEEEEEE

    true, that is the other half. he is still working on that half

  94. 94
    johnlocke says:

    Conflicted but think I’m rooting for the nets tonight…I still believe in a world where we are in 1st place in the east

  95. 95
    DRed says:

    Even Novak’s hitting from downtown now. Turn out the lights.

  96. 96
    elo says:

    We are moving that ball!

  97. 97
    Nick C. says:

    Knicks paying Orlando back for the barrage of threes in the first.

  98. 98
    maxwell_3g says:

    ho was that a foul on shump???

  99. 99
    johnlocke says:

    Horrible call…time to watch the nets

  100. 100
    johnlocke says:

    Another shitty fucking call wtf

  101. 101
    maxwell_3g says:

    oh no… not the hack-a-brew

  102. 102
    DRed says:

    Now that this one is in the books, I have to compliment John Hollinger for absolutely fleecing Toronto today. The corpse of Rudy Gay for Ed Davis is a coup.

  103. 103
    maxwell_3g says:

    please take brewer out

  104. 104
    DRed says:

    maxwell_3g:
    please take brewer out

    What-are you not entertained?

  105. 105
    jp82 says:

    Am I the only one having issues with League Pass? The video has been utterly unwatchable, with the video stopping every ten seconds. The league is ripping off loyal customers. I could not watch tonight’s game at all. Total crap.

    And it has nothing to do with my computer or Internet connection. I steam all kinds of video on different devices, and league pass is the only one that causes this trouble.

  106. 106
    maxwell_3g says:

    im just picturing Edwin Starr (or Jackie Chan) singing “Brew!!!! What is He Good For??? Absolutely nothing!!”

  107. 107
    maxwell_3g says:

    jp82:
    Am I the only one having issues with League Pass? The video has been utterly unwatchable, with the video stopping every ten seconds. The league is ripping off loyal customers. I could not watch tonight’s game at all. Total crap.

    And it has nothing to do with my computer or Internet connection. I steam all kinds of video on different devices, and league pass is the only one that causes this trouble.

    ive had that problem. try this…keeping everything plugged in, turn your able box upside down for a second or shake it a little. it works for me

  108. 108
    maxwell_3g says:

    guys, im not too impressed. we allowed the washington generals to score 97 tonight

  109. 109
    AnonymousODG says:

    Good game. Huge improvement over the last two outings against Orlando.

  110. 110
    lavor postell says:

    maxwell_3g:
    guys, im not too impressed.we allowed the washington generals to score 97 tonight

    I’d be more concerned if in the first half Reddick and Nelson didn’t turn into Frazier and Monroe.

  111. 111
    Douglas says:

    maxwell_3g:
    guys, im not too impressed.we allowed the washington generals to score 97 tonight

    OK, Georges St. Pierre.

  112. 112
    jp82 says:

    maxwell_3g: ive had that problem.try this…keeping everything plugged in, turn your able box upside down for a second or shake it a little.it works for me

    Thanks for the advice. Glad we’re all cool with the league defrauding its own fans.

  113. 113
    DRed says:

    Brooklyn really getting humiliated tonight.

  114. 114
    lavor postell says:

    DRed:
    Brooklyn really getting humiliated tonight.

    It really is pathetic. Reminds me of the death of Linsanity in Miami right before the All-Star break. Nice winning streak but puts things in perspective.

  115. 115
    Douglas says:

    So this is the end of Brooklyn’s new coach honeymoon bump, huh?

  116. 116
    lavor postell says:

    Three convincing losses to Miami on the season now. I don’t see how anybody can view them as a threat in the East. The Knicks and Bulls are the only teams that can push Miami in a 7 game series.

  117. 117
    DRed says:

    The crazy thing about this Nets game is that it was tied at half time and they might lose by 20+

  118. 118
    DRed says:

    The Birdman is out in Brooklyn. Looks like he can still rebound.

  119. 119
    jon abbey says:

    lavor postell:
    Three convincing losses to Miami on the season now.I don’t see how anybody can view them as a threat in the East.The Knicks and Bulls are the only teams that can push Miami in a 7 game series.

    the Knicks’ problem will be getting there, especially if they and Chicago end up 2 and 3.

  120. 120
    maxwell_3g says:

    jp82: Thanks for the advice. Glad we’re all cool with the league defrauding its own fans.

    i was actually serious. it has worked for me. i used to get pissed about it but it worked once and has worked ever since

  121. 121
    JK47 says:

    Amar’e TS% watch: .627

    He was 7 for 7 tonight, all shots from 5 feet or less.

  122. 122
    lavor postell says:

    On January 30, 2013 Danilo Gallinari posted 4 blocks in a game against the Rockets.

    http://scores.espn.go.com/nba/boxscore?gameId=400278399

    This happened

  123. 123
    d-mar says:

    lavor postell:
    Three convincing losses to Miami on the season now.I don’t see how anybody can view them as a threat in the East.The Knicks and Bulls are the only teams that can push Miami in a 7 game series.

    The Nets have maybe 2 impressive wins this season, at OKC and at home vs. the Clips. And I guess you could count beating the Knicks at MSG last time they played. Other than that, they’ve been feasting on the bad and mediocre teams in the NBA. Still not impressed.

  124. 124
    AnonymousODG says:

    JK47:
    Amar’e TS% watch: .627

    He was 7 for 7 tonight, all shots from 5 feet or less.

    That last fadeaway at the top of the paint was not 5 ft.

  125. 125
    nicos says:

    JK47:
    Amar’e TS% watch: .627

    He was 7 for 7 tonight, all shots from 5 feet or less.

    Other than the first couple of games his shot selection has been positively Chandler-esque which is great because there’s very little need for him to be taking 18 footers in this offense. I love that fadeaway he hit in the lane- very Hakeem-like. He also hit a similar shot against Atlanta- it’s really becoming clear just how hard he must have worked in the off-season.

  126. 126
    ruruland says:

    nicos: Other than the first couple of games his shot selection has been positively Chandler-esque which is great because there’s very little need for him to be taking 18 footers in this offense.I love that fadeaway he hit in the lane- very Hakeem-like.He also hit a similar shot against Atlanta- it’s really becoming clear just how hard he must have worked in the off-season.

    The dunk he had from two feet outside the restricted area with a big under the basket was vintage Amar’e.

    These are the kinds of athletic plays he was doing in practice after surgery and during training camp, it was just a matter of getting his conditioning.

    He can be every bit as efficient and prolific (in his minutes) as he was the last few years in Phoenix.

    What’s happened is he’s basically eliminated isolation possessions ( they account for about 5 % of hos total plays) and replaced them with these fantastic post moves that get him a lot deeper.

    Even if he’s lost a little bit of athleticism (which is going to be very minimal because I think he’s going to get even better athletically moving forward), he’s made up for it with the added skill.

    As I said for months, Amar’e had an even better off-season than Melo, who had perhaps his best (and he has had some great off-seasons).

    Had Amar’e not gotten injured,he’d be the comeback player.

    Also, so sick of talking about his defense. A lot of confirmation bias on these boards. His bad possessions are awful, but you shouldn’t judge him on just his bad possessions. His on-ball defense tonight created a lot of problems, and he was great in the trap.

  127. 127
    Kurt says:

    good to know. now i don’t feel as guilty for using first row

    jp82:
    Am I the only one having issues with League Pass? The video has been utterly unwatchable, with the video stopping every ten seconds. The league is ripping off loyal customers. I could not watch tonight’s game at all. Total crap.

    And it has nothing to do with my computer or Internet connection. I steam all kinds of video on different devices, and league pass is the only one that causes this trouble.

  128. 128
    Kurt says:

    “Don’t call it a comeback…”

    JK47:
    Amar’e TS% watch: .627

    He was 7 for 7 tonight, all shots from 5 feet or less.